The Missing Man Behind the Evidence

The Luminaries

This thread follows the search for Emery Staines, whose disappearance drives speculation until his survival and confused account reshape the case.

increasing

Bearing strength in each event

decreasing

Last Seen with Anna Last Seen with Anna from "The Luminaries". Last Seen with Anna A shared night Emery Staines spends the evening with Anna Wetherell and falls asleep at his residence.

Last Seen with Anna from "The Luminaries". Last Seen with Anna A shared night Emery Staines spends the evening with Anna Wetherell and falls asleep at his residence.

Last Seen with Anna A shared night Emery Staines spends the evening with Anna Wetherell and falls asleep at his residence. Anna leaves, later lapses into unconsciousness, and wakes in gaol. Two absences begin By morning Staines cannot be found. His wealth, business, and relationship with Anna make the disappearance impossible for Hokitika to ignore.

The Search Becomes Suspicion The Search Becomes Suspicion from "The Luminaries". The Search Becomes Suspicion A public mystery Missing-person notices and rumours circulate as claims go unattended.

The Search Becomes Suspicion from "The Luminaries". The Search Becomes Suspicion A public mystery Missing-person notices and rumours circulate as claims go unattended.

The Search Becomes Suspicion A public mystery Missing-person notices and rumours circulate as claims go unattended. Men around the Crown connect Staines’s disappearance to Wells’s death and the Aurora gold. Evidence is indirect No one can say whether Staines fled, was abducted, or was killed. Each witness interprets the gap through personal fears and interests.

The Crate Apparition The Crate Apparition from "The Luminaries". The Crate Apparition Moody’s account Walter Moody says a bleeding figure emerged from a crate aboard Godspeed, calling Anna’s name.

The Crate Apparition from "The Luminaries". The Crate Apparition Moody’s account Walter Moody says a bleeding figure emerged from a crate aboard Godspeed, calling Anna’s name.

The Crate Apparition Moody’s account Walter Moody says a bleeding figure emerged from a crate aboard Godspeed, calling Anna’s name. He thinks the figure might have been Staines. The wreck blocks verification Godspeed founders before the cargo can be fully examined. The haunting possibility intensifies the search but does not identify Staines’s fate.

Found at Wells’s Cottage Found at Wells’s Cottage from "The Luminaries". Found at Wells’s Cottage A living witness returns Te Rau Tauwhare finds Staines gravely wounded and feverish inside Crosbie Wells’s abandoned cottage.

Found at Wells’s Cottage from "The Luminaries". Found at Wells’s Cottage A living witness returns Te Rau Tauwhare finds Staines gravely wounded and feverish inside Crosbie Wells’s abandoned cottage.

Found at Wells’s Cottage A living witness returns Te Rau Tauwhare finds Staines gravely wounded and feverish inside Crosbie Wells’s abandoned cottage. Staines is confused about time, place, and his buried gold. Rescue and recovery Tauwhare fetches help, and Joseph Pritchard brings him back toward Hokitika. Staines’s survival turns speculation into testimony, though his memory remains fractured.

A Confused Account in Court A Confused Account in Court from "The Luminaries". A Confused Account in Court Staines explains his absence Staines recounts opium use, hiding in Anna’s room, and being shot while concealed behind the drapes.

A Confused Account in Court from "The Luminaries". A Confused Account in Court Staines explains his absence Staines recounts opium use, hiding in Anna’s room, and being shot while concealed behind the drapes.

A Confused Account in Court Staines explains his absence Staines recounts opium use, hiding in Anna’s room, and being shot while concealed behind the drapes. His account is sincere but disjointed. Consequences remain He pleads guilty to fraud, theft, and dereliction. The court sentences him to labour, while his testimony helps protect Anna from harsher charges.

Evening of 14 January 1866

Late January 1866

Storm voyage, 14 January 1866

20 March 1866

27 April 1866